Get A Quote
View All

Request A Quote

Welcome To Hufnagle Insurance Group

Locally owned and operated, Hufnagle Insurance Group delivers quality insurance solutions to individuals and businesses in Ohio. We specialize in Home insurance, Auto insurance, Life insurance and Medicare Supplements/Advantage Plans, and insurance for ATVs and custom Motorcycles. We're also experts in writing Landlord insurance policies for multiple single-family dwellings.

On the Business insurance side, we specialize in writing Restaurant insurance, Tow Truck insurance, Errors & Omissions insurance, Group Health insurance, Contractors insurance and Agricultural/Farm insurance.

Our team of experienced insurance professionals is committed to helping you find a policy that fits your needs. We focus on providing individualized attention and quality customer service to create an experience that’s difficult to find in today’s market. At Hufnagle Insurance Group, we’ll work with you to ensure that you and those you care about most are protected.

Meet the Owner

Catherine Hufnagle
Catherine Hufnagle


Nationwide logo
Safeco logo
State Auto Insurance Companies Logo
Progressive logo
Anthem Blue Cross Blue Shield logo
Bristol West Insurance Group
Dairyland Insurance
Encompass Insurance logo
Foremost Insurance logo
Founders Insurance
Grange Insurance logo
GuideOne Insurance Logo
Hagerty Insurance logo
Liberty Mutual Insurance Logo
Met Life logo
Mutual of Omaha logo
Smart Choice
Stillwater Insurance Group Logo
Travelers Insurance logo
Untied Healthcare logo
Allstate logo
Hufnagle Insurance Group
Hufnagle Insurance Group
648 Clymer Road, Ste 106 Marysville, OH 43040
Office: 614-574-0238
Fax: 614-385-2075